Soon after that adventure, we had walked into a store and were looking at all the expensive purses & shoes we wish we could buy, when the salesman noticed & commented on our cupcake bag. He then continued to say that “Crumbs is a good cupcake shop, but Sprinkles is the best.” Obviously it would have been a tad ridiculous to then go to Sprinkles and get more cupcakes, so I just made a mental note, and was slightly sad that I hadn’t tried “the best”- although I was quite skeptical since I had just experienced the best sugar rush of my life just 15 minutes before at Crumbs.
Six weeks have passed, and that mental note of crumbs vs. sprinkles was still in my head. Luckily for me, I had to fly to LA for my follow-up knee surgery appt…Between the time my plane landed, and when my appointment was, I had 3 hours to kill. What better way to spend the time then to do the ultimate taste test and end the curiosity stirring inside me?
I arrived at Rodeo drive at 11:35am and went straight to Crumbs Bakeshop. I was once again greeted with 25 cupcakes and friendly workers. Besides the classic chocolate and vanilla cupcakes, the majority of Crumbs cupcakes have fancy names, fancy fillings, and lots of fun toppings on them. This time I ordered “Half-baked”- A marble cupcake with a swirled mix of vanilla buttercream frosting and chocolate cream cheese frosting with a vanilla buttercream frosting filling and topped with pieces of chocolate & vanilla cookies.
I then walked 1.5 blocks down Santa Monica blvd to “Sprinkles.” As you open the door, you read a sign that says, “keep door closed for maximum freshness of the cupcakes”- I knew this place must be serious! I then carefully open the door and am greeted by about 4 girls. They are standing behind a display of about 9 cupcakes. These cupcakes were all very simple though. Standard flavors, standard names, no fancy fillings, no fancy toppings (other than sprinkles- of course!). I decided on the “Peanut Butter Chocolate Cupcake”- chocolate chip studded peanut butter cake with fudgy milk chocolate cream cheese frosting. They start to bag it in a small paper bag, when I stop them and explain how I will be flying and that I would like a box instead to keep it protected. They then explain how the boxes they give out are actually “gift boxes” and would cost me an extra $1….or I could just buy one more cupcake, and in that case they package 2 in a box automatically. Since I was totally against just buying a box, I decide I might as well buy another cupcake- I got the “Red Velvet”- southern style light chocolate cake w/ vanilla cream cheese frosting.
Now that I had cupcakes from both Crumbs and Spinkles, the taste test could begin! I took bites of each, and these are my thoughts- which lead to my ratings below:
- Cupcakes from both shops were equally moist.
- Crumbs cake seemed slightly fluffier and lighter, sprinkles cake seemed a bit denser
- Crumbs Chocolate Cream Cheese frosting is the best- Followed by Sprinkles cream cheese frostings. I was not as big of a fan of the buttercream frosting that was filled within the crumbs cupcake.
- Crumbs cupcakes are about 1.5 times the size of Sprinkles, but about the same price- $3.25-$3.5.
- Crumbs gave me a box for free- Sprinkles wanted to charge me $1.
- Crumbs daily selection was more than double Sprinkles.
- Crumbs cupcakes had fun fillings- Sprinkles did not.
- My favorite overall cupcake for taste was the very first I ate 6 wks ago at Crumbs, the “Artie Lang.” My 2nd favorite was Sprinkles, “Red Velvet.”
- Although the actual quality and tastes of the cupcakes are pretty similar, I have to give Crumbs a higher rating for selection & value. Crumbs gets a 5/5 and Sprinkles gets a 4/5. Either way- you can’t really go wrong- I would say they are my two favorite cupcake stores thus far (I have been to probably about 15 or so..)


